The Institution of Diesel and Gas Turbine Engineers Tel +44 (0)1234 214340
Registered office: Bedford Heights, Manton Lane, Bedford MK41 7PH Fax +44 (0)1234 355493
Registered in England and Wales as a Company Limited by Guarantee No. 07244044 Email email@example.com
Registered Charity No. 1139906 Website www.idgte.org
...the independent technical forum for power generation © 2017 Institution of Diesel and Gas Turbine Engineers
Follow us on
The following are synopses of papers and working cost/operational reports published in the Power Engineer from 1997 to date.
Considerations when Paralleling Generating Sets
Robert Patrick, Cummins Power Generation
Applications where several generating sets are paralleled together are quite common today. Either to supply electrical power to a facility in island mode or paralleled together with the utility in an infinite bus topology.
Standby generators are frequently paralleled together to protect critical applications such as hospitals or data centres in the event of a failure from the utility. In other situations they are used for periodic emergency support to directly back-
Whatever the application, paralleling is a fundamental concept in power generation and invariably introduces specific challenges that must be overcome.
Volume 21 Issue 2 July 2017
Pedro Ponte, Cummins Power Generation
Over the past decade, raised awareness and concern over the effect of engine exhaust emissions has led to the introduction of more and more stringent regulatory limits around the world, leading to a significant reduction of pollutant emissions.
Despite this, the level of air pollution in many places is still problematic. Even though the impact of current legislation has been significant, there are still gaps and not all applications are regulated. With this in mind, on 25 November 2015 the European Parliament signed a new directive that regulates emission limits from medium combustion plants.
World’s first ethane-
Grant Gassner, Paolo Cenini, jell Ove Ulstein and Carlo Contessi -
Originally designed to run on LNG, MDO and HFO, the Dragon class vessels were meant to use LNG as fuel when trading ethane and other LPG cargos. However, logistical challenges with LNG and extremely favourable price development of ethane led to the idea to use LEG cargo boil-
Gas turbine air filter system optimization
by James DiCampli & Jack Pan, GE Power & Water and Mark Arsenault, American Air Filter Ltd
Proper air filtration is critical to the overall performance and reliability of gas turbines. Fuel costs approach 80%of the life cycle cost of electricity. Small gains in efficiency can mean huge savings. With fuel costs of around $16.00/mmBTU and higher in Asia, operational savings can be achieved through improved compressor performance using High Efficiency (HEPA) air filters. Operators can see greatly reduced maintenance costs as a result of a much cleaner engine, quantified by less frequent inspections, fewer shutdowns, and higher availability. HEPA filtration can maintain optimum GT efficiency throughout the life of the filter. This paper will explore the decision criteria required in selecting an optimum air filtration solution, with a goal of maximizing gas turbine availability and lowering operating costs. Through case studies and analysis, the review will explore the impacts on essential filter parameters and their impact on gas turbine operations and maintenance.
How the latest upgrades of Siemens advanced frame SGT5-
Marc Tertilt, Siemens AG Power and Gas, Large Gas Turbines, Service Frame Development
In times of changing market requirements it is important that combined cycle gas turbine operators reflect their opportunities to participate in the energy market and evaluate technical possibilities to stay competitive.
This paper presents an update on Siemens’ heavy duty gas turbine product portfolio and recent products resulting from Siemens gas turbine developments to increase the flexibility of the turbines.
The Siemens SGT5-
Recent new apparatus technologies are also available as a retrofit product for the service fleet to improve either gas turbine performance or operational flexibility with extended maintenance intervals. A consequent application of state of the art technology is a key success factor for the advancement of the service fleet.
By providing an example of an upgrade implementation during a major outage in 2014, this paper demonstrates how power output and efficiency eg after more than 100,000 EOH, can be significantly increased above new apparatus guarantee values by implementing stepwise modernizations, and focuses on the technical details of these improvements.
Based on recent development programs, it is possible to significantly improve operational flexibility by reducing the start-
Hybrid power generation for remote communities and industrial facilities
G Cooper & Sedighy, Hatch, Canada
The demand for cost-
Flowmaster gas turbine system modelling
Sergio Antioquia, Mentor Graphics
In the gas turbine field there are two traditional applications of CFD methods. Three-
Power augmentation of existing CCGTs and OCGTs by injection of hot compressed air
James Macnaghten, CEO, Isentropic Ltd
Isentropic Ltd has developed a compressed air energy storage system intended to address the operational issues of existing and new build Combined Cycle Gas Turbines (CCGT), by allowing for faster ramping, greater turndown, and shifting of power from periods of low profitability to periods of high profitability. The Isentropic® GTI-
Two system variants are identified, incorporated into a single shaft CCGT plant: and increasing resolution at once.
(i) Rapid Response and
(ii) Enhanced Turndown
In this paper, both system variants are assessed in detail with an accompanying explanation of their main features and forecast costs.
Gas turbine performance adaptation for an aeroderivative gas turbine engine power station
Dr Tomas Alvarez – ENDESA, Dr T Nikolaidis, Dr M Diakostefanis, Dr S Sampath and Prof P Pilidis -
Gas turbine based power plant operators are facing challenges in the ever changing and complex power demand pattern from the grid. These arise from a variety of circumstances comprising of changing load demand requirements, fluctuation of fuel prices and environmental pressures. These changes result in modifications to the maintenance requirements where, often, there is not sufficient prior experience.
In this commercial environment the deployment of analytical tools and methods can provide valuable insights to help refine operational decisions with improved knowledge. The work described here is based on an industry-
The first step towards diagnostics is to establish an accurate performance simulation model of the gas turbine under consideration, based on information available in the public domain and inputs provided by the collaborating power plant. This process has been termed as gas turbine model adaptation. This is the exercise described here comprising private company data, public data and targeted estimates by the research team. This exercise of adapting a model based on information publicly available, plant specific data obtained from the power plant and engineering judgement used by the research team has resulted in a strong platform which will act as the foundation for the development of diagnostics methods for the plant.
The Life of a CCGT Power Station Engineering Design Life versus The Commercial World
Peter Tottman, Barking Power Limited
This paper gives a technical review of the development, construction, operation and decommissioning of the 1,000MW Barking CCGT Power Station; setting out the overall performance of the project, both technical and financial, the engineering challenges that the project encountered and its closure. Suggestions are made as to the importance of end-
The power station closed before its technical life had expired, giving rise to an engineering question “How do engineers reconcile their decision making during the design and operation of assets to the realities of the commercial world, so as to adhere to their Code of Conduct requirement that Members shall take all reasonable steps to avoid waste of natural resources, damage to the environment, and damage or destruction of man-
The premature closure of Barking, along with other stations from the Dash-
British Tank Engines of World War I
This paper traces the history of development of engines for British tanks which were used during World War I. The initial engine selection was strictly limited as there was only one petrol engine in production in the UK that could provide the required minimum power within an acceptable size. The diesel engines of the era were too large and underpowered.
The initial selection proved to be a liability in service with a significant list of problems which affected its performance and reliability in action, including the production of clouds of blue smoke that gave warning to the enemy forces of a pending attack.
It was therefore necessary to develop and produce a replacement engine on a top priority basis. Harry Ricardo was engaged to undertake the task commencing in October 1916 and he was assisted with the design and production work by George Windeler, Chief Engineer of Mirrlees Bickerton and Day (who later became President of DEUA). The new engine was in volume production by April 1917 having previously met all the onerous design requirements during the prototype testing phase. It was the first engine to be manufactured in volume by multiple engine manufacturers within the UK with full interchangeability of parts.
The paper incorporates feedback on problems and service results from various publications and also from some unpublished notes by Ricardo.
MAN B&W Stationary Engines – Alternative Fuels
Helle Gotfredsen, MAN Diesel & Turbo
The demand for energy and technological development is increasing worldwide.
Ideas, proven by operational experience on reciprocating engines with the highest possible efficiency level, are subject to renewed interest. This paper deals with the use of alternative fuels in MAN B&W two-
The diesel cycle verified for methanol operation
Helle Gotfredsen, MAN Diesel & Turbo
In 2012 MAN Diesel & Turbo decided to expand the engine portfolio with engine designs that allow operation on fuels with low flashpoints.
Since then, nine engines of the 50-
On 17 March 2015, the first test on methanol was completed at MAN Die-
Efficiency gains by bottoming reciprocating engines with an ORC
Thomas Clark, ElectraTherm Inc.
Reciprocating engine power generation efficiencies are well defined and understood, but significant increases are hard to find, costly and could add additional complexity and maintenance to the end user. One consideration is to investigate the value of the waste heat created by the engine, where in most instances today waste heat is just released to the atmosphere via the engine’s radiator and exhaust.
Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) technology is not new, but in recent years with the development of smaller packaged commercial ORC units, new and existing reciprocating engines are being retrofitted to turn the wasted thermal energy into increased power output. With the commercialization of lower temperature ORC systems, jacket water and exhaust are excellent sources of energy that can be converted into fuel savings. The ORC uses this previously wasted heat for additional fuel free, emission free power. ORC configurations can utilize either high temperature (exhaust), low temperature (jacket water) or a combination of both, demonstrating fuel efficiency gains up to 12%. The cooling power of the ORC also allows it to act as the engine’s radiator – saving on capital and displacing up to 30% of the ORC’s initial upfront cost. Instead of purchasing a radiator, an integrated ORC can become a radiator with a payback. For systems consuming diesel fuel, paybacks in fewer than 2-
This paper demonstrates the potential of low temperature ORC technology coupled to reciprocating engines with applications throughout many industries. Also described is information about technical aspects of ORC machines, including the specific differentiation of ElectraTherm’s technology, fleet experience, robustness of design, and other attributes to consider when choosing an ORC for engine applications. The paper identifies specific examples and experiences from ElectraTherm installations in Europe and North America. Finally, the paper identifies important site considerations and payback scenarios analysis for engine users to have a full understanding of a complete project.
Bryan Holden, C.C. Jensen Ltd and Scott Taylor, Sembcorp Utilities (UK) Ltd
Varnish has emerged as one of the most destructive of oil contaminants in industry. Just like heat, particle and moisture contamination, varnish acts as a so-
A major issue is that varnish is known to be smaller than the size ratings of most filters and, therefore, cannot be removed using conventional pore-
Adsorption is the adhesion of molecules to a solid surface. Adsorptive filtration is the retention of particles to a filter medium by electrostatic forces or by molecular attraction. For better understanding, it is helpful to address four common myths related to varnish removal.
Gianluca de Arcangelis TT Filtration
Gas turbine air intake filtration (AIF hereafter) has become a popular topic in view of the risks and costs provided by letting dirt and corrosive and erosive particles through to the compressor and to the GT hot parts. As a result, nowadays most GT operators seek to install EPA filters.
It is important to consider that traditional filtration technologies are strictly ‘air’ filters, while the environment in real life presents important challenges to separate water, fog and high humidity.
The choice of prefilters is critical since these should aim to guarantee that no free water particles leach through, as well as a long life. This paper provides details of such new filtration technologies.
Uyioghosa Igie, Pericles Pilidis, Daniel Giesecke and Orlando Minervino -
Compressor fouling is known to degrade the performance of gas turbine engines and online washing has shown to be promising in mitigating the effects of fouling. Despite some of the positive findings from actual engine operation or laboratory experiments presented in open literature, there is yet no study that addresses the economic viability of this technology. The aim of this study is to ascertain whether the performance (power) enhancement benefit of washing outweighs the capital investment and recurring cost for a heavy duty gas turbine.
The study applies actual engine data for a case of continuous operation for a period of one year. The engine is known to be degraded due to compressor fouling and results from previous experimental study of online washing has been implemented to predict the changes in the capacity.
Executing online washing every 10 days, at a constant recovery rate of 30% translated to an additional profit of £236,000 (after deducting the operational and maintenance cost of washing) due to improved capacity for the 240MW plant in that year. The return on investment and payback period were calculated and the results indicate 163% and 0.66 years respectively, while washing more than one engine proved more beneficial. The investigation clearly indicates the potential economic benefit of online washing as well as demonstrating the viability for a heavy duty industrial gas turbine engine for base load operation.
MAN B&W ME-
MAN Diesel & Turbo
This paper deals with the latest developments of the MAN B&W ME-
The discussion about and the requirement for lowering CO2, NOx, SOx and particulate emissions have increased operators’ and owners’ interest in investigating future fuel alternatives. The MAN B&W ME-
The gaseous/liquid fuel flexibility makes the MAN B&W ME-
Brian M Igoe, Expert Proposal Manager (FEED) and Andy Stocker, Product Manager SGT-
To meet the growing demand to operate on gaseous fuels with little or no treatment, or use fuels derived from a variety of waste conversion processes Siemens Energy has extended the fuels capability of its’ product range, especially the Dry Low Emissions combustion system. Fuels containing high levels of inert species, nitrogen or carbon dioxide, lower the effective Wobbe Index of the fuels, thus needing increased fuel mass flow to achieve the same energy content.
This paper presents the development process along with the results achieved to accommodate a wide range of fuels. Discrete changes were required in the DLE burner hardware allowing fuel flows to be achieved at similar supply pressures and combustor pressure drop as for standard fuels thus ensuring combustion characteristics were not compromised.
Some applications are presented and discussed covering both on-
This programme demonstrates the ability of the Siemens DLE combustor to accommodate a wide range of fuels.
Dr Jim Mooney, University of the West of Scotland
The widespread adoption of wind power generation as a means of providing electrical energy has brought significant changes to electrical power distribution systems in the United Kingdom (UK) and the Republic of Ireland (ROI). These two countries are both remote from continental Europe with limited interconnection to the European electricity distribution network, and also have limitations in terms of grid interconnection within and between these two countries. As the amount of grid-
Hydrogen acts as a storable ‘energy carrier’ that can be either converted back into electricity thus providing a balancing service to electricity generators and suppliers, or used as a ‘zero emissions’ fuel for other applications, such as transport.  Hydrogen (H2) can be produced from water and electricity by means of electrolysis. It has a very high energy density and can be stored in caverns practically without loss in virtually unlimited quantities for unlimited periods. This makes it ideally suited for storing energy for periods of weeks or whole seasons. Furthermore H2 can be converted back into electricity using fuel-
Flexible conventional generation plant, with full flue gas abatement
Peter Grima, Enemalta Corporation, Malta
The Maltese electrical system is quite typical of small island power systems, and differs significantly from larger European ones in a number of key areas. Enemalta Corporation is the state owned vertically integrated utility and Malta has derogations from the Internal Electricity Market Directive on the requirement to open its market and on third party access to the network, making the Maltese Electricity Market effectively a single buyer/single seller structure. Typical of such small systems, is the lack of economies of scale which both increases operating costs and makes the usual way of unbundling and privatisation unfeasible.
At present Enemalta operates two Power Stations, which supply all the electrical power needs of the Islands of Malta and Gozo. These stations with a total combined nominal installed capacity of 620MW, are interconnected together by means of the HV distribution network. Malta has no indigenous primary energy resources and therefore Enemalta relies entirely on imported fuels, mainly heavy fuel oil and light distillate, although there are plans to construct a floating LNG storage and regasification plant at Marsaxlokk, adjacent to Delimara Power station. Once the interconnector is commissioned and put into service by the end of 2014, the older power station at Marsa will be decommissioned.
Volume 17 Issue 4 (December 2013) Paper 596
Maximum Buquet -
Frequency stability is one of the prevailing concerns of a Transmission System Operator (TSO) whose aim and duty is the reliable operation of the grid. Operation of the electrical grids must be reliable, handling future generation mix, whilst often being constrained by existing infrastructure. To help meet these challenges, TSOs have developed grid codes. Among other requirements, grid codes define minimum performance requirements of generating units connected to the grid.
This paper focuses on one important aspect of grid codes, which is grid frequency support.
Christian Engelbert and Darrell Helas, Siemens Industrial Turbomachinery Ltd, Lincoln
Siemens Lincoln site has been designing and manufacturing industrial gas turbines since the late 1940’s.
With the introduction of its latest gas turbine, Siemens now proudly looks back at decades of engineering, manufacturing and operational expertise.
This paper looks at the heritage of Siemens’ small industrial turbines through to today’s business, the current product portfolio and typical applications. It examines how a ‘Product Family’ has been evolved via technology programmes. Scaled axial compressor technology is discussed as an example. An insight is given to how this ‘evolutionary technology’ approach has been applied to the latest SGT-
Ten years hard labour in Mombasa
Graham Dilliway, BSc CEng FIMechE FIET Hon FIDGTE
This paper examines all aspects of the work, skill and dedication that in the last twelve years have gone into the engineering, design, construction and operation of the Kipevu 2 diesel power plant in Mombasa. The plant is internationally recognised both by lenders and investors as a great success in terms of its operating reliability, power availability, energy dispatch and heat rate.
The paper also looks at some of the near-
Narowal 213MW diesel combined cycle -
Brian Kinsella and Stephen O’Gorman, Mott MacDonald Ireland Limited
Pakistan is a developing economy and its projected load growth in electrical power demand over the next ten years is expected to be at least 1,500MW per annum. There are many power plant technology alternatives being considered to meet this demand including hydro, open cycle gas turbine (OCGT), combined cycle gas turbine (CCGT), conventional steam turbine generation (STG) and diesel engine driven power plant. This power growth is located in the major cities of Pakistan, for example, in Lahore which is located in the Punjab region and has a population of circa 8.5 million. Power cuts during the Summer peak demand period are regular occurrences. This problem is compounded in certain less populated areas of the country where one such area is Narowal in the Punjab, a town which is located approximately 10km from the Indian border and 120km North East of Lahore.
Implementing improvements to gas turbine air inlet filtration -
Scott Taylor and Stuart Lax, Sembcorp Utilities (UK) Ltd
This paper looks at an operator’s experiences and learning during the implementation of improvements to a gas turbine air inlet filtration system during the first few years of operation.
The operator, Sembcorp Utilities UK (Sembcorp), is a subsidiary of Singapore-
Gas processing, side stream alternative use
Stefan Falten, Wartsila Finland Oy
Gas conditioning produces different gas/liquid mixes that in the traditional downstream engineering process end up in defined products and by-
Addressing the cause of varnishing in gas turbine lubrication systems
John A Platt BSc(Hons) AIMechE FIDGTE, Global Technical Manager, Castrol Power, BP plc
Varnishing in modern gas turbine lubrication and control systems is an increasingly common problem which often results in serious impact on reliability and availably of the plant.
The problem of varnishing in lubrication systems is only too well known, but is generally not well understood. This paper seeks to impart an understanding of the lubricant properties and characteristics which affect its ability to resist varnish formation and, with reference to over 800,000 hours of successful operation under varying service conditions, to demonstrate that by careful formulation and appropriate selection of the lubricant, together with correct monitoring and control, it is possible to effectively address the root cause of varnishing thereby delivering a valuable contribution to reliability, availability and optimisation of the asset.
Diesel power for UK rail traction
Trevor Owen CEng CMarEng MIDGTE FIMechE FIMarEST
One of the major applications of diesel power in the UK since the 1950s has been for rail traction purposes. This article traces the use of diesel power from the earliest shunting locomotive in the current main line locomotives, but excludes diesel multiple units (DMU).
Volume 16 Issue 2 (June 2012)
Marcel Skarohlid, Josef Bozek Research Centre of Engine and Automotive Engineering, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Czech Technical University in Prague
The removing/clearing of CO2 from gaseous fuels as adulterant is a contemporary trend. To the contrary with this trend the presented paper describes benefits of CO2 fuel content on basic engine parameters like indicated mean effective pressure, indicated efficiency and NOx production. This paper analyses trade off between air excess, ignition timing and CO2 fuel mass fraction in detail.
Protecting critical equipment, reducing operating costs and safeguarding against downtime through on-
Dr Stuart Lunt, Kittiwake Developments Ltd, UK
Oil condition monitoring is a vital part of integrated asset health management. With an increasing impetus towards real-
Volume 16 Issue 1 (March 2012)
Adam Duzynski, Czestochowa University of Technology, Poland
As early as the 1970s, the Warta SA waste treatment plant in Czestochowa, and actually its predecessor – the Warta SA Commercial Water Company, undertook, on the initiative of Prof Karol Cupial from the Institute of Internal Combustion Engines and Control Technology (IMTiTS PCz) – presently the Institute of Thermal Machinery at the Czestochowa University of Technology – Poland’s first trials on the utilisation of biogas, a by-
The propulsion of merchant ships: The case for LNG -
T W Page, IEng, MIMarEST, FIDGTE, Wartsila UK Ltd
The fundamental changes in ship propulsion over the last century or more have been driven by economical pressures and resultant technological development. The first major change from coal firing to oil was a gradual process during the first half of the 20th century.
Volume 14 & 15 Issue 4
Operational Report (combined edition) 2009/2010 Data
Compiled by Tom Woodford, Guernsey Electricity
Reducing fuel consumption on the field by continuously measuring fuel quality on electronically fuel injected engines
Mr Patrice Flot, CMR , France, Mr Alain Meslati, CMR, France and
Mr Thierry Delorme, Ecole Centrale Marseille, France
This paper describes the sensor’s hardware and software technologies as well as the expected engine combustion performance improvement resulting from the new control parameters. This sensor can also be used to protect the engine from poor quality fuel.
The History of the Industrial Gas Turbine (Part 1 The First Fifty Years 1940-
Ronald J Hunt CEng FIMechE FIDGTE , Thermal Power Consultant, Power + Energy Associates
This history of the industrial gas turbine documents the history of the development of gas turbines for land based, locomotive and marine applications. A key part of the history is the documentation of all manufacturers and gas turbine models produced each year since 1940. The aircraft engine is excluded from the scope of the work and only referred to in as far as it related to the development of industrial machines gas turbines. It has not been possible, up to the time of publication, to include every company who were active in the development of industrial gas turbine however the research work is continuing and it is planned to add to this history in due course.
This paper (Part 1) deals with the first fifty years of development of the industrial gas turbine from 1940 to 1990. It is planned that a second paper (Part 2) will be presented later in 2011 covering the period 1990 onwards.
Volume 15 Issue 1 (March 2011) -
Efficient combustion of Glycerol and other low cetane fuels in the diesel engine
John McNeil Aquafuel Research, Kent Science Park
This paper covers the ultra efficient low exhaust emission burning of the bio-
The paper specifically deals with the patented principle behind ignition and efficient combustion of glycerine and other low cetane fuels, together with the manner in which the process lends itself to CHP applications.
Stationary MAN B&W MC-
Helle Gotfredsen, MAN B&W
In recent years, the stationary diesel engine market has seen a demand for units running on biofuel. The nature of this demand is driven by the desire to be CO2 neutral, based on reliable, fuel-
This demand is being met by modern marine application derivative medium speed diesel gensets and two-
This paper deals with the application scenarios of such engines and their biofuel capability and describes the installation examples of such engines.
Dhekelia ICE -
Knud Hvidtfeldt Rasmussen, Burmeister & Wain Scandinavian Contract A/S
Dhekelia Internal Combustion Engines – ICE -
This paper describes the plant, the engine design with a single turbocharger, and the measures taken on design, logistics and construction for accomplishing the fast track execution.
At the time of ordering the plant, suppliers of large components were operating at peak load causing many difficulties resulting in long delivery time. This caused extreme demands for fast action during the erection on site. Due to the single turbocharger arrangement, the structural vibration condition deviates to some extent from well-
The plant performance in terms of power and efficiency has been fully satisfactory. As the plant is operated in parallel with steam turbines, the engines are in most of the operation period used with daily start and stop, utilizing the optimal flexibility of the diesel engines. The performance of the engines has been closely monitored with regular port inspections. Very low wear rates of cylinders and piston rings have been demonstrated.
An analysis of micro gas turbines for UK domestic combined heat and power
A Clay and G D Tansley, School of Engineering and Applied Science, Aston University, Birmingham
For Domestic Combined Heat and Power (DCHP) applications, large component losses are inevitable when using a Micro Gas Turbine (MGT) prime mover of 1kW or less due to low mass flows and high operating speeds. MGT research has developed advanced technological strategies to address the particular issues of bearing platform, impeller design and impeller manufacture. This paper seeks to establish the performance criteria for an alternative, low cost MGT DCHP machine via an analytical discussion based on adiabatic, air standard cycle analysis.
A competitive recuperated MGT was deemed suitable only when slightly optimistic turbomachinery efficiencies were considered. The introduction of pressure drops from heat exchange combined with poor component performance produced shallow inflection points on a system efficiency vs. pressure ratio curve. Selecting a pressure ratio below that which corresponded with maximal efficiency reduced shaft speed with some compromise in system efficiency. Both the use of efficient turbomachinery components (at low cost) and an effective heat exchanger with low pressure drops are essential for a successful MGT DCHP unit.
The evolution of gas turbine compressor cleaning
Russ Gordon, R-
This paper looks at the evolution of gas turbine compressor cleaning, and relates it to the various technical advances in the development of gas turbines. It starts with a reminder of how fouling affects the aerodynamics of the compressor and hence the necessity for compressor washing.
The early days of cleaning compressors with very basic materials and methods are described, as used on the relatively unsophisticated types of gas turbines of the time. Moving on through the 60s and 70s and the introduction of single crystal blades and super-
The development of wash fluids is also presented, from tap water up to the latest sophisticated blends of chemicals.
Evolving nozzle design and positions in the intake plenum is examined in some detail. Increasing air flows, and developments in compressor blade design, have influenced the importance of droplet formation and hence nozzle design.
Environmental legislation is covered briefly, with its influence on gas turbine development and hence cleaning methods.
The degree of automating wash systems is discussed as the efficiency demands on the industry become greater.
Carbon capture and storage implications for CCGT development
K Foy, Parsons Brinckerhoff
This paper describes the various methods of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) applicable to Gas Turbines (GT) and CCGT plant, focusing on the three most advanced technologies: post-
The technical issues involved in both CCS equipped new-
The impact of the different types of CCS on operation of CCGT and SCGT is discussed.
The cost of power generation from thermal plant fitted with CCS is presented in comparison with other power generation options.
The paper also includes a discussion of possible developments in the future CCS industry, including transportation and storage networks.
A McMurtrie, AIM Energy Ltd
Biomass is seen as being an important renewable energy resource and a key component in helping to deliver the Government’s greenhouse gas emission reduction targets as set out in the Climate Change Act 2008, ie a 34% reduction in the UK’s net carbon account by 2020, rising to 80% by 2050 (versus a 1990 baseline) and, the UK’s target under EU legislation to produce 15% of its energy requirement from renewable sources by 2020.
This article primarily refers to combustible biomass material typically categorised as ‘plant biomass’, although many of the challenges faced with utilising this fuel source equally apply to other biomass materials. To date, viable, medium sized industrial and commercial scale biomass has proven challenging to implement due to the added complexity and cost, versus say traditional fossil fuel heat/steam production, power or CHP plant. Increased complexity typically arises out of fuel; its availability, storage and handling, the physical plant size and duty, environmental compliance, capital cost, etc. This has meant that the number of developments delivered to date has fallen short of what might have been expected.
This paper seeks to outline some of the key challenges and considerations to be addressed in assessing whether biomass offers a sustainable and viable option to companies and in doing so may offer some insight into why many organisations in the UK have so far rejected or ‘parked’ a potential biomass solution. However, whilst highlighting these challenges, I also hope that some additional guidance may allow interested parties to also consider the ‘positives’ and thus encourage them to give some serious thought to the opportunity that biomass may have to offer them in their specific situation.
Product Development and test program for aggressive gas engines
V Carey, K Tellier, G Delafargue and D Squirrell, Exxon Mobil
Engine designs, operating conditions, and environmental factors place increasingly higher demands on lubricants for all gas engines, but even more so those operating on the aggressive gas applications associated with sewage and landfill gases. This paper will focus on the product developed specifically for such applications, and where the fuel contains high amounts of silicon along with other contaminants, presenting an especially difficult lubricating environment.
Increased engine reliability, extended time between engine overhauls, and reduced operating costs were the primary objectives of the development program. This paper will cover general aspects of the laboratory development program and present documentation on the excellent field performance achieved.
Operational Report 2009
Compiled by Tom Woodford, Guernsey Electricity
Y G Li, P Pilidis and E Tsoutsanis, Cranfield University and M Newby, Manx Electricity Authority
In the volatile energy market effective use of the available technological, energy and financial resources is now, more than ever, highly pursued. In a combined cycle power plant, gas turbines are the prime mover of power generation. Therefore, detailed understanding and monitoring of gas turbine performance, health condition and associated costs have a deep impact on the decision making process concerning the plant’s operational and maintenance strategy.
In this context, research collaboration between Manx Electricity Authority (MEA) and Cranfield University has been carried out since 2001 and a series of technologies and software have been and are still being developed at Cranfield University and some of them have been integrated into MEA’s Combined Cycle Gas Turbine Power Plant in Pulrose, Isle of Man. During this constructive and successful collaboration period, the University has been fortunate to acknowledge the industrial needs and make significant academic contributions through ongoing research projects jointly supported by both MEA and EPSRC. On the other hand, MEA has valued the complexity of asset management concerning the gas turbine and the combined cycle, therefore enhancing its trading and operational capabilities through the application of developed performance, diagnostic, trading and economic analysis software.
This paper presents the main framework of this collaboration by emphasising the research undertaken on the gas turbine performance simulation and diagnostics, combined cycle performance analysis, trading and economic analysis to support MEA in their decision making process.
Barking Power Station generator core failure and repair process
G Smith, Thames Power Services
Core failures on running turbo-
J P van Buijtenen, TriO-
The principle of the ORC (Organic Rankine Cycle) is well known already for decades. However, most of the present ORC-
The ORC process demands a very high expansion ratio, at moderate turbine inlet temperature. A standard 175 kW (gross power) unit is able to run at optimum speed for turbine and pump on the same shaft as the high-
This paper will describe the novel turbo-
The power and control systems design for the UK future aircraft carrier
Lt Roy Casson, Colin English, Simon Newman and Lt Cmdr Ian Timbrell
At 65,000 tonnes the Future Carrier (CVF) represents a step change in British force projection capability, with the ability to embark more than 30 aircraft of various types to undertake a range of differing roles. Behind such a ship there must be a generating capability that is able to provide large amounts of power for both the ship's propulsion and services, rapidly, reliably and economically. An Integrated Full Electric Propulsion (IFEP) system has been selected as the most suitable for this task.
At the heart of this system are two MT30 Gas Turbine Alternators (GTAs), each capable of producing 35MW of electrical power to propel the ship at high speeds. This speed is necessary to launch advanced fighter aircraft and helicopters to enable this modern capital ship to perform a multitude of tasks. A variety of challenges are currently being faced to integrate these large GTAs into a power and propulsion system that also features Diesel Generators (DGs), power electronic converters and Advanced Induction Motors (AIMs). Solutions to these issues are being developed by the Aircraft Carrier Alliance (ACA), which is responsible for procuring the ship, working closely with the MoD and the engine manufacturer to provide a robust, reliable and responsive power source that is fully integrated with the propulsion system.
The demands of a new running regime for slow-
Tom Woodford, Guernsey Electricity Ltd
Since the island of Guernsey became electrically connected to mainland France in 2000, a significant, yet highly variable, proportion of the island’s electricity demand has been imported through the submarine cable interconnector. The existing power plant on the island, comprising five slow-
This paper examines some of the issues associated with operating the slow speed engines over recent years, describes some of the particular and unusual problems encountered, and the steps taken to overcome them. The paper concludes with a look forward at the continuing operation of the engines, and the uncertainty surrounding their life expectancy.
The management of variability and intermittency of electrical power supply
Dave Andrews, Consultant
This paper outlines how Wessex Water utilises its multiple small-
Volume 12 Issue 2 (June 2008)
MAN Diesel A/S, Copenhagen, Denmark
Recently, fuel oil prices have risen to unprecedented levels, bringing fuel oil consumption of diesel engines more into focus than for a long time. At the same time, exhaust gas emissions in general and CO2 emission in particular are top priorities.
Volume 12 Issue 2 (June 2008)
Alva A Shortt, Bateman Power & Energy
In the last fifteen years large heavy-
The objective of this report is to verify whether DME is a clean, renewable and economic alternative fuel that could be viably used in a simple cycle gas turbine power plant to generate peaking electricity.
Gaseous and particulate emissions control from stationary engines and turbines
Tim J Benstead & Christoph M Heinisch, Johnson Mathey Catalysts
Ever tightening legislative controls on transport emissions mean that the relative impact of air pollution from stationary sources such as chemical plants, industrial processes and heat and power generation applications, is now more significant than ever.
The exhaust from stationary reciprocating engines and gas turbines contains a cocktail of harmful gaseous pollutants including carbon monoxide (CO), oxides of nitrogen (NOx) and unburned hydrocarbons (HC) and hazardous air pollutants (HAP). Together with emissions of particulate matter (PM), if not controlled, they can lead to major health problems and contribute significantly to climate change and environmental pollution.
Today, a veritable toolbox of pre-
This paper profiles a number of case studies illustrating the range of state-
The use of biomass derived fast pyrolysis liquids in power generation: engines and turbines
Cordner Peacocke, Conversion & Resource Evaluation Ltd
Power production from biomass derived pyrolysis liquids has been under development for over 15 years. If technically successful, it would make decentralised bio-
The development of the TD2010 engine concept
R A Bickerton, Deutz UK
The industrial diesel engine manufacturing company of Deutz AG identified the need to expand its range into smaller displacement engines. To further this strategy the company purchased the Technical Centre and new small engine range from the administrators of Lister Petter Ltd in 2004. These engines were designated the Deutz (T)D2009 and D2008 range of engines. To further expand this range of engines, Deutz UK were requested to consider the design of a larger version of this family.
This new engine was to be designated the TD2010. The engine was to share the (T)D2009 and D2008 engine concepts and hence complete the engine “family”.
David Andrews, Wessex Water
Wessex Water has about 4.5 MW of continuously operating biogas CHP generation capacity. This is provided by spark ignited gas engines. It also has about 32 emergency standby diesel engines, totally 18 MW whose primary function is to power essential services – sewage works and water supply works during power failures. They are also used in a number of ways, which is called collectively Load Management, and which includes routinely supporting the National Grid. These generators have a 4 minute start up and paralleling capability, and are currently being modified to enable start ups in less than one minute.
Operational Report – Stationery engines, gas engines and gas turbines with alternative technology interfaces 2007
John Blowes & members of the Operational Report Committee
Modern engine control systems for common rail engines, gas engines and dual fuel engines
Rob S Arends, Woodward Europe Controls & Fuel Injection Equipment
Due to recent emission legislation and the current increase in oil price on the world market as a result of the energy demand, gaseous fuels are becoming more and more a valuable source to produce power. Within the OEM market of medium bore engine builders a series of developments is ongoing to either develop a dual fuel application or create a propulsion version out of a land based Spark Ignited gas engine.
Dual fuel application within the range of 30 to 60cm bore are seen in the LNG tanker market and are strongly upcoming in the electric power generation, both new and as retrofit package.
Experiences of Peterborough Power Station during 2005 overhaul
Ken Henderson, Centrica Energy
This paper is intended to give an insight into the work carried out during the Major Overhaul at Peterborough Power Station. Its main focus will be the work carried out on the two Frame 9E Gas Turbines but will also touch on some of the other work undertaken during this period.
Utilisation of low BTU gases in spark ignition reciprocating engines – requirements and experiences
Martin Schneider, GE Energy -
Increased ecological consciousness and the knowledge of limited reserves of primary energy in the form of fossil fuels make it necessary to utilise available energy sources economically. Cogeneration plants with gas engines produce electricity and heat at decentralised locations, where they are required. They offer optimal efficiency in the utilisation of energy with minimum environmental burden.
Gas engines are presently powered primarily with natural gas, biogas or propane. The use of “special gases” like producer gases, coke gas, pyrolysis gas or gas from gasification processes gas with low calorific values or changing gas compositions with respect to emission limits of the common air quality requirements is a new challenge for gas engine development. Highly sophisticated gas engines with intelligent engine management systems now allow the utilisation of gases, which could not be burned a few years ago. Jenbacher AG has already installed cogeneration plants running with coke gas (55% H2 content), pyrolysis gas from domestic waste gasification (35% H2 content), gas from wood chip gasifier and producer gas from the chemical industry with an extreme low heating value (0.5 kWh/m3).
These experiences have shown that the gases from gasifier or pyrolysis gas from waste can be used in gas engines, as long as the gas fulfils certain requirements.
Power Management Systems in gas turbine power stations
Roger Haycock, Freelance Engineer & Consultant
Two power management systems (PMS) that have been retrofitted in gas turbine power stations will be reviewed. The addition of a PMS to an existing power station will improve reliability, reduce ‘blackouts’ and eliminate many of the operator’s mundane tasks. The paper will also review the main features of a PMS explaining how it can be implemented in hardware and software. The basic logics are independent of the hardware platform, which can be chosen to be similar to existing control systems in the plant.
Working Cost and Operational Report – Stationary Engines and Gas Turbines 2006
John Blowes & members of the Working Cost Committee
An Emerging Technology – Performance and Condition Monitoring of Diesel Engines and Gas Turbines via Acoustic Emission Measurements
Ryan M Douglas, Heriot-
Demand for condition monitoring of diesel engines and gas turbines has advanced at a rapid pace in recent years. Stimulated by the continual drive for improved performance, be it for mechanical, economic, safety or environmental reasons, operational safety margins have diminished and in some cases have been replaced by a delicate balance between optimal operation and damaging conditions. Consequently, the need for monitoring and for better-
This work describes the novel use of AE measurements to provide information pertaining to the running condition of diesel engines and to a lesser extent, gas turbines. For diesel engine applications an AE sensor placed on the external engine surface is shown to reveal detailed information regarding engine events such as fuel injection and valve activity. Most promisingly the ability to offer non-
The findings regarding the ring/liner interface are established through testing on large, 2-
Volume 10 Issue 1 (February 2006)
Andy Leach, Renewable Power Systems Ltd
Microturbines are an exciting new product offering advantages for small-
The Ecotran Rotating Gasifier – Generating Power from Waste
Peter Stain, Ecotran Energy Ltd
The Ecotran Gasification process is designed to gasify waste fuel in an environmentally friendly manner. The system converts the waste in a rotating gasifier to produce a quality pyrolysis gas that can then be used to fuel either a reciprocating gas engine or a gas turbine for the generation of electricity.
Either dry or wet waste fuel is delivered to the plant. If the fuel is wet, it may be discharged into a centrifuge-
Unlike other systems the Ecotran system used the char (fuel with the gas removed) to heat the gasifier and not the gas produced. The char is cooled then fed by a screw conveyor to a small grinder where the char is ground into a powder and stored in a hopper. Oils and tars that are carried over with the gas are removed by a quench system and oil separator and stored in a storage vessel. From storage the oils are used as a fuel along with char via burners to fuel the secondary converter.
Waste heat from the gasifier and, if required the waste heat from the gas engine, is used to provide steam energy to support the fuel drying and cooking ovens, buildings etc.
The current Ecotran design is capable of handling 0.5 tonnes per hour of dry fuel with a wide range of waste materials and these can typically produce up to 0.77MW electrical power. Designs are available for plants of 0.5 t/h, 1.0 t/h, 2.5 t/h, 5 t/h and to handle up to 10 t/h dry waste material into the gasifier.
Developing a secure power supply for an island community
Jim Crombie, IOM
This paper looks at the process and reasoning by which decisions on energy supply were taken. It is in two parts; firstly describing the historical context and circumstance that initiated the need for additional energy supplied, followed by a description of the newest plant provided to meet that need.
The Development of the High Speed Industrial Diesel Engine
Ron Bickerton, Independent Consultant
This paper is aimed at introducing the design, application and testing techniques used to develop the modern high speed diesel engine. The paper will compare and contrast the engine types, technologies and development techniques between the large engine and its smaller high speed cousin. It is hoped that the paper will provide an insight into the challenges faced by the design and development of the modern high speed industrial engines and where possible that will be directly contrasted with the author’s experience in the large engine industry.
Hydrogen, Heat and Power from Waste
Andy Brown, Progressive Energy Ltd
A move towards energy sustainability requires not just the utilisation of natural resources (such as wind, tide, solar and hydro), but also the exploiting of primary energy sources in ways which result in minimal or no addition to those mechanisms understood to lead to global warming in particular. The options for this latter criterion are limited, especially in a nuclear-
Mick Parker, Rolls-
Over the past 40 years the main driving force behind the development of the gas turbine has been in its application as an aircraft propulsion unit. The large aero production base and the demand for more efficient engines justified the huge investment in technology necessary to develop the aero engine to its current state. To maximise the benefit gained from the successful development of its aero gas turbines, Rolls-
At the same time, there has been considerable focus on domestic waste, brought about by the realisation that landfill does not represent a responsible solution, either to resource use or to the prevention of the release of a number of the same gases that are being blamed for global warming.
An ideal solution to both of the above would be to utilise what domestic waste cannot effectively be recycled, to contribute to the primary energy deficit. Mass burn incineration has been fulfilling this role for some years. As a technology, it is efficient in reducing landfill (about 90% by volume and 75% by weight1), and also releases energy, the heat released being used to generate electricity, though at relatively low efficiency (about 20%2). Incineration, however, is not able to substitute directly for transport fuels, and there are still residual concerns about some combustion products (such as dioxins) which makes the consenting of new facilities very difficult.
An alternative is to gasify the waste and produce hydrogen gas. This technology produces less (or no) landfill, generates electricity at a higher efficiency (about 35% for a 100MW facility), offers a direct substitute for transport fuels, and produces none of the harmful combustion products ascribed to incineration plants.
This paper describes the waste gasification technology, the production of hydrogen, and its use as a substitute fuel in prime movers – internal combustion (spark ignition) engines and gas turbines and fuel cells. It is based on a study that was commissioned to investigate the practicability of deriving hydrogen using energy from waste, initially by Gloucestershire Waste Action Trust (GWAT), whose work was taken over by The Recycling Consortium, funded by Cory Environmental under the Landfill Tax Credit Scheme. Support has also been obtained from the Energy Saving Trust.
Working Cost and Operational Report -
Compiled by W T Owen
Gaz de France Energy: The first LNG carrier of a new generation
Barend Thiijsen, Wartsila Raisio, Finland
For the past forty years, steam turbine installations have dominated propulsion and electric power generation onboard LNG carriers. The ease with which these installations can utilise boil-
Initially encouraged by the latest developments in its gas engine technology, Wartsila started looking for more economic and environmentally friendly ways to power LNG carriers. Machinery alternatives with two and four-
The first dual-
Design and Development of the Rolls-
Lars M Nerheim, Rolls-
RR Bergen gas engine development goes back to 1984. At that time, after careful evaluation of possible alternatives, the spark-
The Future for Liquid Biofuels
John McNeil, Sittingbourne Analytical Laboratory Ltd
Using renewable liquid biofuels on a large scale would help to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and also make a valuable contribution towards providing diversity and security to energy supplies. Liquid biofuels could be used for bother power generation and road transport, and biofuels that offer particular potential include animal fats, vegetable oils, used cooking oil, biodiesel and bioethanol. All of these materials have physical characteristics similar to petroleum fuel oils and the liquid biofuels can be stored and shipped in much the same way as petroleum oils. Animal fats and vegetable oils are particularly safe to handle because they have high flash points and are stable, inert, non-
All of the above mentioned liquid biofuels are capable of being burned by internal combustion engines, although some biofuels may require modified combustion conditions to burn efficiently. For example, it has been established that animal fats and vegetable oils burn much more efficiently in a diesel engine if the combustion atmosphere is enriched with oxygen.
Given appropriate Government encouragement, biofuel production could be a very substantial industry. For example, if 1Mha of arable land and 3Mha of marginal land were devoted to growing the feedstocks required to produce biofuels such as biodiesel and bioethanol, the biofuels could have a potential energy content of up to 650 PJ/year, enough to make a significant contribution towards the energy requirements of the country. The processed biofuels could have a commercial value, excluding tax, of over £5 billion/year.
Substantial Government support would be required to encourage a thriving biofuel industry. Biofuels cost more to produce than petroleum fuels and to be competitive the biofuels would require significant tax breaks, particularly when used as road fuels. For example, the UK Government has proposed a road duty tax incentive of 20 pence/litre for both biodiesel and bioethanol, i.e. a fuel duty of 26 pence/litre instead of the 46 pence/litre duty currently imposed on petrol and diesel. However, with a duty of 26 pence/litre neither biodiesel nor bioethanol would be competitive with conventional road fuels, and the proposed tax break is unlikely to be enough to encourage the substantial investment needed to develop a large biofuel industry.
First Prototype of the high efficiency Isoengine
Mike Coney and Claus Linnemann of RWE Innogy & Kimihiko Sugiura and Takayuki Goto of Mitsui Engineering & Shipbuilding
For more than 10 years, Innogy (now RWE Innogy) has been developing a new type of high-
Kipevu 2 Independent Power Project
Graham Dilliway, Power-
Power projects in the developing world are often plagued with major operational problems, and frequently there is a regular pattern to the reasons why. While international aid agencies make significant contributions to economic growth in developing countries, through the construction of electrical infrastructure, aid packages are often tied to plant produced in an agency’s home country, and are often little more than industrial subsidies. Additionally, parastatal utilities often purchase the very latest technology without carefully examining its service history, the availability of local operational skills and resources, and the cost of specialist support from plant manufacturers.
This problem was recognised in the 1980s when the World Bank Group reviewed their loans for electrical power projects. The bank then published the wide-
IPP schemes solved many of the problems that dogged aid package power plants, but have not been a universal panacea. Many of the early schemes were negotiated during energy crises, and the resultant PPAs were often highly disadvantageous to the purchaser. In addition, the majority of IPP schemes are financed in US dollars, and the power purchaser and ultimately the consumers have to bear the impact of exchange rate fluctuations.
Some 15 years after EPUES publication, IPP schemes have matured. Significant adjustments by power producers and power purchases have enabled both sides to achieve value for money, given the right technology, fuel, operating resources, training and contractual framework.
Kipevu 2 Independent Power Project in Mombasa, Kenya, is such a scheme.
E A Kerez
This paper deals with operating experience with a number of Brown Boveri Gas Turbines in industrial service, particularly those installed at Beznau Power Station, the largest plant of its kind so far built, belonging to the North Eastern Swiss Power Supply Company (NOK) which plant includes two units, one of 13,000kW and one of 27,000kW. Reference is also made to a 5,400kW gas turbine set running at the ARBED Steel Works as Duelange (Luxemburg) as well as to the three sets installed at a Cement Mill in Pertigalete in Venezuela.
Volume 8 Issue 2 (May 2004) Working Cost and Operational Report – Paper 540
Working Cost and Operational Report – Stationary Engines and Gas Turbines 2003
Compiled by W T Owen
Report on Heavy-
Development of MAN B&W RK280, the most powerful 1,000 rpm engine in the world
Dr E R Karimi, MAN B&W Diesel Ltd
MAN B&W Diesel Ltd is introducing the most powerful 1,000 rpm engine in the world for fast ferry, marine and industrial applications. The design utilises the operational experience gained on the successful RK270 engine, which has a world leading position in the large fast ferry market. The clean sheet design incorporates many improvements over existing engines including electronic fuel injection, underslung crankcase, rigid modular camshaft, single gear train and built-
The most significant change in the engine has been the way it was designed utilising industry best practice concurrent engineering techniques, 3D modelling, predictive engineering, design reviews, risk analysis and multi-
Three configurations of the engine, 12, 16 and 20 cylinders will be released to the market during 2003, at 450kW/cylinder plus 10% overload and after successful running of the first engines in service; the full release rating of the 20RK280 will be 10MW.
Volume 8 Issue 1 (February 2004) – Historic Paper
The function of the Heavy Oil Engine in connection with the General Supply of Electricity
Distillate fuel FOCUS
Norman Pearce, Alfa Laval
The face of power generation has changed significantly during the last twenty years. There are greater demands to protect the environment and a greater desire to optimise operating profits through high reliability and availability of plant.
In the UK, and many other parts of the world, natural gas has replaced coal as the main power generation fuel. It is readily available in most countries and is seen as the most environmentally friendly of the fossil fuels.
Privatisation and advances in gas turbine and combined cycle technology have made the gas turbine the preferred power generator for power stations of 100MW and upwards.
But as security of plant operation is paramount, distillate fuel oil is normally available as a back-
This paper addresses the problems that poor fuel quality management can present to operators and provides a new solution for economically maintaining good quality clean fuel.
Volume 7 Issue 5 (December 2003) – Historic Paper
The Recovery of Lubricating Oil
Alfred J Wilson
The Cummins QSK78 Heavy Duty Engine
Robin J Bremmer, Cummins Engine Company Ltd & Hirofuni Kizawa, Industrial Power Alliance
A new heavy duty 18 cylinder, vee configuration, 77.6 litre displacement diesel engine producing 2,610kWm (3,500bhp) at 1,900rpm has been designed and developed by the Industrial Power Alliance and introduced into production by Cummins Inc. The Industrial Power Alliance is a joint-
Electricity Supply in War Time, as effected by the improvements in Heavy-
A H Dykes & W T Townend
Safety at Gas Turbine Power Applications
Roger C Santon, Health & Safety Executive
Gas turbine plants driven power plants have become larger and more popular in recent years. Many are based on gas turbines within acoustic enclosures. Complex high-
Operating Experience with a 750kW Gas Turbine
G B R Feilden
This paper concentrates on the practical aspects of operation on the basis of experience gained during the first twelve months of endurance running of the Ruston and Hornsby 750kW gas turbine. The plant is the first prototype of a production industrial gas turbine to be tested in Great Britain.
Working Cost and Operational Report -
Compiled by J H Blowes
Design and development of the new Rolls-
Lars M Nerheim, Rolls-
Traditionally, Bergen has been producing auxiliary engines for the merchant fleets – practical and reliable engines which were simple to operate and service, but still of a flexible design which also made them suitable for smaller propulsion duties in our local areas. Later they were also successfully developed for the new oil and gas industry.
This has resulted in a concentration on engines of mainly 250mm bore since the “R” engine of the early 50s, and these have been steadily developed and renewed through the “L” type and “K” type up till the currently time.
In 1997 the decision was taken to start the development of a new engine platform at Rolls-
The Turbec Microturbine from Prototype to Commercial Product
S Ernebrant, Turbec
Deregulation of the power industry and a demand for lower emissions are fuelling a move toward small-
Turbec AB, a Swedish manufacturer with roots in the power generation and the automotive industries recently started delivering its first gas turbine product, the Turbec T100 CHP. The T100 CHP is a 100 kWel combined heat and power solution based on a small, highly integrated turbine generator system.
Caterpillar High Efficiency Engine Development G-
Roy Toyne, MAN B&W Diesel Ltd, Regulateurs Europa
The demand for higher output gas engines for power generation and gas compression applications encouraged Caterpillar to extend the current gas engine program up to 6MW. The result is a new large bore spark ignited gas engine with high efficiency and low emission levels.
The basis of this development is the well proven robustly built HFO engine, the 16CM32. This engine has the capability to withstand high mechanical loads and is designed to produce low thermal loading. By increasing the bore diameter, the power reduction, compared to the diesel engine, was minimised with minimal changes to the engine frame. All other gas specific components such as cylinder heads, pistons, liners and fuel system were redesigned.
To reach the targets of bmep, efficiency and low emissions, a spark-
In the autumn of 1998 the first prototype G-
This paper reports the salient points of the G-
This paper is based on a presentation at the 2nd Dessau Gas Engine Conference, June 2001.
Wartsila 64 The biggest and the most powerful four-
P Tonon, Wartsila Italia SpA
Ship size has increased in the past years and consequently so has the demand for more powerful engines.
The Wartsila 64 with its 2MW power per cylinder and 640mm bore is the world’s largest medium speed engine ever built. The 6 to 18 cylinder configuration covers power output from 12,060 up to 34,920kW. In this power range 200 to 280 ships are delivered yearly equipped with 2 stroke main propulsion engines.
Working Cost and Operational Report – Stationary Engines and Gas Turbines December 2001
Compiled by J H Blowes
International Marine Exhaust Emission Legislation
A A Wright, American Bureau of Shipping
The adoption in 1997 by the MARPOL Diplomatic Conference of Annex VI to the MARPOL Convention will, on ratification, extend this range of controls to limiting the air pollution from ships. A major part of these controls, both in terms of their detail and impact on the marine industry, will be in respect of the exhaust emission limits to be introduced. At this time, these exhaust emission controls will cover NOx emissions from diesel engines and SOx emissions from all types of combustion machinery. In addition, there are also controls covering certain oil fuel quality matters. In the case of the NOx controls, these are already having a significant effect on the engine design and certification process. In contrast, the SOx controls will be largely operation based. However, even with these, and to some extent the oil fuel quality controls, there are actions to be taken over the period prior to the entry into force of the Annex in order to ensure future compliance.
This paper gives a detailed overview of these exhaust emission requirements and how they will function within the overall ship certification process which will be required by the Annex.
Remote Monitoring of Large Diesel Engines
Roy Toyne, MAN B&W Diesel Ltd, Regulateurs Europa
Since the early days of any machinery, that was powered by anything other than man, there has been seen the need to monitor its operation. From the author’s observations of man’s early attempts at powered machinery, it was more than justified.
Monitoring generally consisted of a man with a good set of eyes and ears. Later we added the clipboard and the checklist or chart and, I guess the term Watchkeeper had a very literal meaning. The objective has always been to see that the machine is functioning correctly and to try to intercept problems before they became serious, either to the machine or anyone in the vicinity. As we have become more conscious of cost and safety issues so these basic needs have become more prominent.
Engines and specifically large diesel engines have come a long way since their beginnings and the level of reliability that we expect and receive from them would have been unheard of 50 years ago. Materials, surface finishes, lubricants and the use of sophisticated design techniques have all worked together to achieve this. However, as the means to achieve reliability have moved forward, so have the expectations of increased power and reduced size and weight. There are many engines that spend their life operating very close to their maximum speed and power ratings. So despite the advances in reliability it would be a brave or possibly foolish operator who decided that he did not need to monitor the operation of his engine.
As the engine technology has advanced so have monitoring techniques. The big revolution came with the introduction of digital techniques and the all encompassing PC.
Thus to the title of the paper: remote monitoring. If we cannot dispense with the man or woman to interpret the data, we can at least put that person into an office environment and allow them to monitor a number of engines. We can present the data in a user-
Gas Turbines and Spark Ignition Gas Engines for industrial CHP
Charles C Heap, CCH Consulting
Gas turbines are widely accepted as prime-
Oil Mist Detection as an aid to monitoring engine condition
Brian J Smith, QMI Ltd
As diesel engines become progressively more efficient by burning fuel more effectively, the only remaining significant potential for operational cost saving to be exploited is to introduce features to ensure that unnecessary maintenance is reduced. Owners and operators of diesel power plants are increasingly seeking ways to replace preventive maintenance schedules based on operational hours by on-
A Sustainable Energy Strategy for Wessex Water
David Andrews, Wessex Water
This paper puts forward some thoughts towards a Sustainable Energy Strategy (SES) for Wessex Water. The paper first discusses possible criteria for sustainability as they apply to energy strategy. It then proceeds to describe the activities of the Wessex Energy Team and the energy options that the company could explore in the pursuit of a sustainable strategy.
Working Cost and Operational Report – Stationary Engines and Gas Turbines 2000
Compiled by J H Blowes
Diesel Particulate Filter Regeneration and Catalytic NOx Reduction Augmented with Heat Recovery and Active Hydrocarbon Injection
Krishnan Balakrishna, Marc D Rumminger, Dave T Eveland & Bradley L Edgar, Ceryx Inc
Understanding particulate filter regeneration and lean NOx catalysis is important for the design and operation of a diesel exhaust after treatment system that can simultaneously reduce NOx, PM, HC and CO.
The experimental data presented includes soot loading and unloading (filter regeneration) curves from tests conducted on the dynamometer under several different conditions. A comparison is made between the performance of uncatalyzed diesel particulate filters (DPFs) and catalyzed DPFs based on the rate of soot loading and burnoff. The effect of cell density on the performance of the DPFs is discussed. Filter regenerations have been carried out both by burnoff at high load conditions and by fuel-
Experimental results indicate that the catalyzed DPFs regenerate at a much faster rate than the uncatalyzed DPFs at the same engine exhaust conditions. DPF regeneration was demonstrated by generating an exotherm via the oxidation of supplementary hydrocarbons. It was found that supplementary fuel injection also helped to increase the conversion of NOx within the operating windows of lean NOx catalysts (LNCs).
Treating Fuels in the New Millennium
Richard Kelly, Alfa Laval Ltd
The quality of marine bunkers has over the past 25 years influenced the development of cleaning systems dramatically and contributed largely to the establishment of fuel oil quality standards. Amongst other things, these have assisted the user and equipment manufacturer in operation and product development issues respectively. This paper deals with the most significant developments in the cleaning of these heavy fuels by centrifugal separation and addresses the potential fuel-
Economic Considerations of Power Plant Refurbishment versus New Build
J H Blowes, Diesel Consult
The only way to assess economics and risks is to fully understand the options.
Consider the starting points:
Green field site, new building and modern equipment – all compatible and following well-
Existing building and facilities. Proven equipment in need of overhaul.
Green field site utilising refurbished equipment.
It is of course necessary to quantify the extent of refurbishment that in turn has a very significant bearing on the refurbishment approach and cost.
Volume 5 Issue 1 (January 2001)
D A Gillespie, IDGTE
The challenges to the suppliers of marine propulsion systems in the coming decade from the perspective of an individual company should in many respects be no different to the challenges that existed in the past. Today however there is an added dimension that arises directly from the rate at which new technology is being developed and applied.
Company survival essentially depends on possessing a product, or a range of products, that is sought by the targeted market. Market demand alone will not guarantee success however, as in a competitive environment, this will largely depend on high market share and sustainable growth, which in turn are highly dependent on the product satisfying the current and perceived future requirements of the market-
The H.A.M. (Humid Air Motor) System: A simple way to reduce NOx emissions in diesel engines of all sizes
The evolution of the diesel engine faces great obstacles and challenges with regard to the creation of environmentally friendly designs. One of the major drawbacks of the modern diesel engine is its high emission of NOx. Unfortunately, measures aimed at decreasing NOx emissions in diesel engines will almost always conflict with high efficiency.
Diesel Engines and Gas Turbines in Cruise Vessel Propulsion
H W Koehler, MAN B&W Diesel
The Celebrity Cruises’ gas turbine-
Volume 4 Issue 5 (October 2000)
The last two articles in this series for students and practical engineers discussed basic engine performance parameters, the engine frame, pistons and connecting rods. This article touches upon the design and performance of the fuel injection equipment; the pumps, pipes, injectors, nozzles and fuel cams that are essential for efficient engine operation.
Managing Lubricating Oils in Service to Optimise Life and Minimise Cost
J A Platt, Castrol UK Ltd
In a business where efficiency is the keyword and the drive for ultimate performance unrelenting, stresses on lubricants are ever greater. More severe operating conditions demand higher specification products inevitably resulting in increased lubricant cost. This coupled with higher disposal tariffs and stricter environmental controls makes it ever more important to make oil last longer. But the cost of replacing and disposing of lubricant is often small compared with the associated cost of machine downtime and lost output involved in carrying out an oil change, or even worse, in repairing plant which has failed without warning. Nowhere is this more critical than in today's highly competitive power generation industry.
Correctly applied, Oil Condition Monitoring (OCM), can be an effective tool not only in optimising oil change intervals, without compromising the protection of plant and equipment, but also in the early detection of impending problems allowing timely corrective action to be taken thereby reducing maintenance and replacement costs and minimising unplanned downtime resulting in lower overall operating costs.
Volume 4 Issue 4 (July 2000)
Working Cost & Operational Report Stationary Engines and Gas Turbines 1999
Compiled by J H Blowes
Four Stroke Marine Diesel Engines
G P Baecker, MaK (London) Ltd
When in 1992 MaK introduced the new M20 engine with a power range from 900kW to 1,710kW at 900 to 1,000rpm it was the result of an intense internal evaluation process. From the beginning the following targets were set:
1. The design should be transferable
2. To allow production in Europe
3. Ease of maintenance
5. IMO exhaust gas regulation
Volume 4 Issue 2 (April 2000)
What influences component design and why are particular materials important? George Murray explores the anatomy of the diesel and suggests some possible answers.
Application of Computer Systems in the improvement of Power Generation Operation and Maintenance Management
R J Hunt, Power + Energy Associates
In almost every region of the world advances in technology, deregulation of markets, privatisation and liberalisation have had an astounding effect on the management of power plant operations and maintenance. These changes have produced a growing need for power plants to use the best available technology and computer systems in the improvement of operations and maintenance of power generation facilities, i.e. Computer Management Systems.
New, Long Life, Self Cleaning Lube Oil Filtration for Diesel Engines
R Andrews, Cummins Engine Co
The role of the lube oil filter system on diesel engines is to protect critical engine components from harmful particles. Maximum engine life is dependent on the proper use of an oil filter system designed for that engine. This paper reviews a new low maintenance filtration system for use on diesel engines as designed by Alfa Laval Ltd and developed by Cummins Engine Co. This new filter system, named Eliminator, is comprised of an integral full-
The Industrial Trent Gas Turbine
J M Hutchinson, Rolls-
In the increasingly competitive market of distributed power, plant operators are becoming more demanding of equipment reliability, availability and cost of ownership. Against this backdrop Rolls-
The Phased Development and Implementation of a Large Cogeneration Plant
S A Jameson, P R Gladhill & P Bayada, National Power
This paper examines the development of large-
It focuses on the issues surrounding the selection, installation and commissioning of key plant items such as the gas turbine, heat recovery steam generator, boiler and steam turbine.
Finally it considers the importance of integrating the new steam plant with an existing (expanding) system which has large variations in steam demand.
Volume 3 Issue 4 (July 1999)
J H Blowes & D Gillespie
Diesel and gas engine capabilities have improved rapidly since this prime mover became commercially viable in the early 1900s. Recognising the growing importance of this efficient form of power generation, a group of power station chief engineers founded the Diesel Users Association in 1913. This Association is now The Institution of Diesel and Gas Turbine Engineers (IDGTE).
As industry became progressively more reliant on diesel and gas engines for driving factory machinery and for electric power generation, a range of problems were encountered during the early period of rapid growth, which were discussed within the forum of the Diesel Users Association. This service feedback, incorporating valuable statistical data on operating experience, that is still collated and published today, has assisted engine makers and ancillary equipment suppliers over the years to refine their products and meet the demands of the market.
Working Cost & Operational Report Stationary Engines and Gas Turbines 1998
Compiled by J H Blowes
Waste Heat to Water
N Pearce, Alfa Laval Ltd
Clean, high quality water is essential for reliable power plant operation and can be a significant extra cost if an adequate, reliable supply is not available. Yet frequently diesels and gas turbine power systems are installed in remote locations where the only source of water is from sea, river or bore hole water.
The paper reviews the thermodynamics of desalination, and how greater utilisation of waster heat from power plants can provide high quality water for industrial and domestic consumption.
Gasification of Refinery Residual Oil and Subsequent Generation of Electricity
J A G Brown, Progressive Energy & J Griffiths, Jacobs Engineering Ltd
The increasing pressures to achieve environmental improvement have required changes in almost every energy-
Gasifying such residues has been commercially successful on a small scale for over 40 years and larger plants for total disposal can provide an alternative fuel for modern CCGTs.
This paper describes the nature of the refinery's problem, the gasification processes possible, and treatment of the gas to provide an ideal fuel. Brief mention is made of the diverse feedstocks which can be used, including biomass, coal, Orimulsion® and MSW. Some current commercial projects are described, demonstrating that this technology is accepted worldwide.
Volume 3 Issue 1 (January 1999)
P Berridge, Ballyohannon Farms, Co Wexford, Ireland
Production of electrical power burning biogas is now an established procedure using a simple method of converting diesel engines without the complication of ignition coils and spark plugs. (Converted petrol engines, having a much lower compression ratio, do not run efficiently.)
The Diesel Gas Engine
Dr T A Bradshaw, Bradshaw Consultants
With the increased availability of gas and the requirement to minimise emissions, not only of noxious gases but also of carbon dioxide, has come a renewed interest in gas burning engines.
For large power demands the gas turbine is proving most attractive, particularly the very high efficiency aero derivative, but for smaller powers the reciprocating engine is still a preferred choice. There are however an increasing number of alternative ways of burning gas in an engine, to include the gas diesel engines. A brief description of each technology is provided with a suggestion for the direction that engine development may take.
Stirling Engine Powered Micro Co-
J Harrison, Sigma Elektroteknisk
Combined Heat and Power (CHP) has significant potential for the more efficient use of fossil fuels and the reduction of CO2 and other polluting emissions. It also offers the possibility of reduced infrastructure requirements, (and consequent environmental impact) both in terms of large scale generators and the associated transmission and distribution facilities, by the nature of "embedded" generation. Indeed, the evolution from central generating plant to distributed generation is seen by many as a natural response to environmental demands and to the commercial pressures imposed by an increasingly competitive market.
In the UK, economic considerations limit existing CHP technologies to the size range of 30kWe and above, although tax advantages make 15kWe (and even smaller) viable in some countries. This is primarily due to the high unit maintenance and capital costs of equipment. The internal combustion engines generally applied are of limited durability, reliability and efficiency and produce relatively high levels of noise and air pollution.
Stirling engines offer better energy efficiency and reliability, lower exhaust emission and noise levels. They also permit a greater flexibility than internal combustion engines in the choice of fossil fuels and alternative renewable energy sources. Stirling engines are potentially prime movers in CHP systems on the micro scale, operating effectively at outputs as low as 800We.
Turbines & Reciprocating Engines Producing Power from Natural Gas Pressure Reductions in the Supply System
A Cleveland, Cleveland Eng Services Ltd & E A Wright, WFL Eng & Management Services Ltd
The authors have been involved over a number of years with promotion of the use of turbine and reciprocating engines as a means of recovering energy from the necessary pressure reductions which occur in natural gas transmission and distribution systems. The paper reviews the thermodynamics involved, the types of machines which have been used with emphasis on a remarkably successful reciprocating machine and the economics of application. The paper also considers the potential in the United Kingdom for expander generators and addresses the question as to why there are so many installations operating in continental Europe and not in the UK.
Working Cost and Operational Report -
Compiled by J H Blowes
Large End Bearing Temperature Measurement Development, Testing and Application
N Catsaras, Mobil Shipping, A Devaux of SEMT Pielstick & F Laurent of CMR
For more than twenty years Controle Mesure Regulation (CMR) and Societe D'Etude des Moteurs Thermiques (SEMT) Pielstick have collaborated and gained great experience in the protection of main bearings on diesel engines.
In order to improve the monitoring of the crankshaft line, CMR developed a new temperature sensor for the large end bearings (TB2). This sensor has been patented. The paper describes the principle of this sensor and shows the possibility of measuring the temperature of rotating parts with the TB2.
In service examples of installations of the TB2 will be used to highlight the interest of this measuring equipment.
A detailed description of a preliminary test carried out by SEMT Pielstick on a test bed engine will be shown to demonstrate the capabilities of the instrument and its performance. Information is given on the temperature behaviour of the large end bearing with speed and load variations.
An account of a long term test by Mobil Shipping Co. is based on a three year trial on several in service engines.
Finally, reference is made to the rules edited by the International Association of Classification Societies (IACS), regarding the monitoring of all bearings of the moving parts of the engine, and the possibility of the TB2 satisfying these requirements.
Producing Independent Power
J Hakola, Wartsila NSD
Several different parameters are used to measure the performance of the power unit. Naturally the economical parameters are usually in the balance sheet, but on the non-
Mark Barnes, H Leverton Ltd
This paper describes the process of installation of a Caterpillar 3616 HFO generating set into an existing generation facility. Whilst not a terribly difficult undertaking, the effort involved cannot be underestimated.
The opportunity arose in 1994 to perform this task at a wire factory located in the west of England. The issues arising in the course of this undertaking are described in detail, together with a synopsis of early operational experience.
Emission Control – Two-
J O Hellmann & K Aabo, MAN B&W Diesel A/S
General awareness of environmental issues is increasing rapidly. Diesel engine makers were first involved in questions regarding exhaust gas emissions in the field of stationary applications.
A study of the exhaust gas emissions from a diesel engine represents a challenge to both the engine designer and to makers of exhaust gas treatment equipment. It is also a valuable tool for reaching a deeper understanding of the engine combustion process. Such understanding has led to more serious treatment of environmental issues in connection with the design and application of diesel engines.
Anticipating this development, MAN B&W initiated studies of the emission characteristics of their engines some fifteen years ago. These studies included work on finding techniques for reducing the exhaust gas emissions to comply with current as well as anticipated future rules. The main focus has so far been on reducing the emission of nitrogen oxides, NOx. As a result, we have already supplied emission control equipment for a number of ships and stationary plants.
Within the IMO (International Maritime Organisation) there are now discussions of emissions limitations in the form of air pollution at sea. Authorities in various parts of the world are taking similar steps. An example is the proposed EPA (US – Environmental Protection Agency) rules currently under discussion. Proposals from both authorities are dealt with in the paper, and technologies designed to meet the proposals are discussed. Furthermore, the World Bank has recently issued a proposal for environmental guidelines based on the IMO rules.
Volume 1 Issue 5 (October 1997)
Geoff Scrivenor, ETSU
This paper provides an overview of how Renewable Energy Technologies have progressed in recent years, the part they play in a very diverse UK Electricity Supply Industry now nearly open to full competition, and the enablement mechanism currently in place to promote their uptake. Consideration is given to their commercialisation and how effectively they are likely to compete alongside conventional power generation into the future. Although environmentally friendly, the argument that “it’s a good thing” is unlikely to sustain a Renewable Energy industry and the technologies will ultimately need to be commercially and technically attractive for their survival in an industry where privatisation and competition have driven all costs in the supply chain steady downwards.
Gas Turbine Condition Monitoring Systems – An Integrated Approach
Celia Fisher, Stewart Hughes Ltd
The capability of a condition monitoring system for effective monitoring of faults and incipient problems depends on the design and integration of the system as much as the sensors and signal analysis techniques used. The first step is to define the requirement which can typically be summarised as follows:
1. reduce the number and severity of failure incidents between scheduled overhauls
2. improve the diagnostic and prognostic capability so that maintenance can be planned and will target the components wit incipient or development faults
3. enable the calculation of engine usage and prediction of remaining life
4. minimise consequential damage
5. achieve the above with the minimum sensor fit
Other, more ambitious targets include putting the engine on condition; and assessment of the long term effects of ingested materials or lower quality fuel on the engine life and performance.
The high plant availability and low maintenance cost requirements currently demanded by operators necessitate efficient, cost effective monitoring systems.
Volume 1 Issue 4 (July/August 1997)
Simon Walton, Newage International Ltd
Non linear loads such as semi-
Most generators produced today can cope with quite high levels of waveform distortion without detrimental effect to themselves, however, most problems occur with electronic power device control equipment trying to synchronise with a distorted waveform.
Many questions have been asked regarding the application of generators for powering non-
Working Cost and Operational Report – Stationary Engines and Gas Turbines 1996
Compiled by J H Blowes
Design and Development of the 12VP185
J N Ramsden, Paxman Diesels Ltd
Design criteria are set out for a compact high-
Volume 1 Issue 2 (April 1997)
M Hooper, AHS Emstar
With the ever increasing demands to reduce energy costs, environmental emissions and increase plant efficiency, consideration must be given to the application of Combined Heat and Power (CHP) as an effective form of energy provision.
It is often thought, that conventional boiler plant and systems can be converted to an effective CHP scheme without incurring significant cost and disruption to services. In some instances this is true however, it is important that in every case we must undertake a detailed site survey. This will have the added benefit of giving a true and accurate proposal for such a scheme, it will in addition identify quickly and at minimum cost any areas that will counteract the successful implementation of CHP on site.
Power Generation from Biogas
J H Blowes
The IDGTE made a significant contribution to a “Technical Survey of Power Generation from Biogas” commissioned via a main contractor by ETSU, the Energy Technology Support Unit, for the Department of Trade.
This forms part of the support provided by ETSU to promote cost effective use of non fossil fuels and advancement of knowledge, being shared objectives of the IDGTE.
The writer has utilised his own knowledge and experience, and that of other members who specialise in this field, to compile the IDGTE contribution – to include some additional notes.
The paper may therefore be used to provide an initial insight into the topics discussed, with a view to the reader then consulting specialists in the particular area of interest.
Charles N Yakum
Electric power generation, transmission, and distribution systems represent substantial investments for the electrical power supply industry, and so are customarily protected from faults through the use of relays and circuit breakers. A current transformer (CT) for measuring electric currents at certain strategic points along the higher power systems has been an integral component, not only in such protective schemes, but also for metering purposes. A conventional CT for these high voltage applications is inherently large and expensive due to electrical insulation requirements. As electric power supply systems are increasingly operated close to optimum economic efficiency, the cost and limitations of the conventional CT become gain limiting factors. Therefore for high efficiency gains, improved plant and system monitoring methods are required. To maximise profit, such methods rely upon evolving the use of new technologies such as optical fibre based sensing systems. An example of such a system which has been considered as offering significant benefits but has yet to be fully accepted commercially is an optical fibre current monitoring system for use on high voltage power lines and circuit breakers.